Friday, April 10, 2015

Homemade Laundry Detergent Review: Liquid vs. Powdered

There are so many blogs and Youtube videos already circulating the same two recipes for liquid or powdered laundry detergent. I found the how-to on youtube for both, using Fels-Naptha soap, Borax, and Washing Soda. While I don't feel the need to do a full how-to tutorial on both, since there are hundreds already out there; I did wonder, which one is a better product for my effort. My criteria for good laundry soap is one that works well, is cost effective, easy to use, washes the most loads, and gets the cloth diapers clean without leaving a residue. I didn't really want to add another labor intensive chore to my life, so ease of making it and how frequently it needs to be made is a consideration. I first made the powdered, which works alright and was simple to make. However, we went through two batches of it pretty quickly. I also had a hard time keeping it evenly mixed, as it seemed the white powders sifted to the bottom of my tub of detergent, leaving all the soap shreds on top. So, while it was easy to make, I had to make it fairly often and I found myself over-analyzing the ratios of each spoonful.

Then we made the liquid laundry soap, which uses the same stuff, but involves water and some time at the stove. I used a five gallon brew bucket for the resulting soap concentrate because I like that it has a tap, and I refill my laundry soap bottles with half water and half soap concentrate.


I didn't think it would work as well, because it was only 1 bar of soap, 2 cups of Borax and 1 cup of washing soda, if I remember correctly. So, it used less soap than the powdered kind. I found however, that it works really wonderfully, I actually like it better than the powdered kind. It makes 4.5 gallons of concentrate, which becomes 9 gallons of liquid detergent. It leaves the clothes really clean and fresh looking, feeling and smelling. It was a little more work, but honestly, not a difficult process, and it is a LOT of loads, is lasting a long time and is very cost effective. It gets the heavily soiled cloth diapers really clean without leaving a lot of residues. I really prefer using liquid soap over powdered in general, and this is no exception. It is a little more work to make, but I since I make it so much less often and is a nicer product to use, it is worth the effort to me.

2 comments:

  1. I've made the liquid stuff and really like it, but G doesn't seem to care for the gloppiness of it. He also has an 'in' with some dude at work who apparently has a line on bulk detergent for cheap, so....

    It's nice to know what's in the products you use, and I'd like to use the homemade stuff but He Who Does Much Laundry must be allowed a preference to, I suppose. :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. He Who Does Much Laundry over here gave me the brew bucket with his blessing. It's a huge gesture. I want to make the leap to making the actual soap bar that is shredded into the liquid laundry soap recipe so that I know exactly what is in it. That is the next step. I like that this does the job with less soap. We don't use any soap directly on the current baby. We chose cloth diapers to limit the exposure to carcinogens and so forth, so it makes sense not to introduce them into the cloth diapers via laundry soap. I like that both recipes have fewer chemicals than commercial laundry soap because we grow small people who wear clothes against their skin all day...well...most days.

    ReplyDelete